Most likely, you have your Registry Visibility set to "Hidden", meaning people can only access your Babylist if they have your unique URL.
Here is how the visibility settings work-
(1) Public: Makes your registry searchable only on Babylist.
Option for Google (must check box): Makes your registry available on Google. It can take Google up to two weeks to add your Babylist to their results but your Babylist is instantly searchable on our site.
(2) Hidden: Makes your Babylist unsearchable. Friends and family need to have your unique link to access your registry.
For all of these options, you can choose whether or not your visitors need a password to access your registry. The default is that no password is required, so if you want to add a password, make sure to check the box that reads "Visitors need a password to access my registry".
Here is how to update your Visibility Settings:
Are you using a Computer?
To update your visibility settings, click Update (located on your registry, just below your registry title) or you can go to Registry > Settings > Registry Visibility. If you're logged in, you can go directly to that page here.
Are you using the app?
Tap on the Menu button in the upper left corner > Registry > Visibility & Privacy. Select your privacy setting and click "Save."